Multiple domain names are often used by website owners to target specific countries and
languages, and keywords. But there are serious consequences for your site's search engine rankings if you
don't understand how the search engines treat having multiple websites that are all related. This Search
Engine Optimization Tip discusses how having more than one domain name can impact your website's performance
in the search engines, and how best to deal with the issues involved.
In the heady days of the Dot-Com Boom, there were oceans of people and businesses registering domain names that contained the names of celebrities, famous companies, movie and television titles, and anything else they thought would bring in the big bucks when they sold the rights to them. Domain names are not quite the hot properties that they once were since the registrars have set up rules that protect trademarks and copyrights. But the biggest reason that catchy domain names are no longer the Holy Grail is that Internet users are now accustomed to using search engines to find products and services, rather than blindly typing in things like "bestcarprices.com". But the desire for higher rankings in the search engines has revived a great deal of momentum to the practice of buying many domain names and having them all point at the same website - or more precisely, the same webpages.
Search engines like Google do give some weight to the contents of the URL for a webpage in their ranking algorithms. It's not a huge factor, but some hucksters are so anxious for any benefits that they'll register dozens of domain names that are variations of the primary keywords for their sites just to get that small boost. However, there's a fly the size of Brazil in this ointment. It's the mirror site or duplicate content filter that all search engines impose if they detect duplicate content. The search engines have several concerns in this regard. First of all, allowing multiple URLs to point to the same content degrade their search results. Second, each webpage in the index of a search engine consumes valuable resources in their networks and its understandable that they don't want to waste these resources on SPAM or even innocent copies. When Google detects duplicate content, it tries to select the best version of the page, (the "canonical version"), and devalue the copies. The common phrase "duplicate content penalty" is a misnomer, since there is no overt penalty involved. But, the problem is that you don't get to pick which copy is selected as the canonical version and which one gets ignored. So you can have half of your content indexed under one domain, and the rest on another, all of which kills your internal linking benefits, and damages your overall rankings on both domains. Using a different language to convey the same information is NOT duplicate content, so don't worry about that.
|Purpose of Domain||Best Solution|
|Website Branding||It can be a good idea to buy the common Top Level Domain (TLD, as in ".com", ".net", etc.) variations of your primary domain name in order to protect your brand. For example, if your company or product name was "example", and your primary domain name was "example.com", you would want to buy "example.net", "example.org", "example.biz" and "example.info" in order to prevent others from leveraging your brand name to siphon off your traffic or to post unflattering information about you. Once again, you should install 301 redirects on all of the secondary domain names pointing back to your primary domain.|
|Targeting A Country||Buy the Country Code Top Level Domain Name (ccTLD, as in ".uk", ".ca", etc. ) for the target country, and localize the content for language spelling and currency. All pages that are duplicates or near duplicates should have a rel="canonical" tag pointing to the original page on the primary domain. Duplicate content is generally not an issue for ccTLDs versus generic TLDs for the same owner, but it is always best to customize the content of each site to the target country to differentiate it from the other domains. In summary, use rel="canonical" on duplicate pages, have limited cross-linking among the domains, use the Geo-targeting tool in Google's Webmaster Tools on generic TLDs, and make the common domain ownership clear in the registration records. Do not automatically redirect users based on their IP address. Give users clear navigation links to the other domains instead. See Google's advice on Multi-Regional and Multi-Lingual Websites for more information.|
|Targeting A Language||Don't use a separate domain name for each language. Add a subdomain or a subdirectory to the primary domain, and link to it from the primary domain's main page. When necessary, any pages that are duplicates written in the same language should have a rel="canonical" tag pointing to the original page on the primary domain. Again, translated content is NOT duplicate content.|
|Targeting Keywords||Install 301 redirects on the secondary domains pointing to the primary domain. This is best if you want to catch misspellings of your primary domain name. If you're buying keyword-based domain names, the choice is murky. Building a second non-redirected website with a keyword-rich domain name can be an option, but it obviously takes twice the work since you'll have to create unique content and separate links for the additional domain. Still, if you install a 301 redirect, all you'll get is type-in traffic and essentially no traffic from the search engines.|
The basic advice is to never have multiple domain names pointing to a single website unless you have set up 301 redirects to a single URL: that is, the URL for the primary domain name. It is doubly or triply difficult to get enough link popularity spread among multiple domains in order to have any positive effects, as opposed to simply promoting and enhancing a single website with a single domain name. Many companies and organizations buy extra domain names that are common misspellings of their preferred domain name, or might otherwise be mistyped by users or misused by competitors. In those situations, of course, the best practice is still to install 301 redirects back to the primary domain name.
But if you have a compelling reason to use multiple domain names, such as using country-specific Top Level Domains (ie. ccTLD's like ".uk" or ".au") for their search engine ranking advantage in terms of geo-location factors, you need to take steps to avoid problems by making sure that there is limited duplication among the sites you operate. Using a different page design can help, but it's the actual text within each website that needs to be as unique as practical considerations allow. Google has recently posted an article on Multi-Regional Sites that discusses this issue in great detail.
If vital information is on the company's main website and it can't
be rewritten for one reason or another, then you should use one of the following alternatives:
If you already have multiple domain names in use, then you should merge them into a single, primary domain with 301 redirects. The solution is to use server control methods to automatically redirect all requests for pages in the secondary domains to the URL in your primary domain name. The server must return a "301 Moved Permanently" response code in order for the search engines to properly re-assign the link popularity and to update their internal records of the page's true URL and to avoid any problems. Any other response code returned by your secondary domains will, at best, prevent the link popularity to pass on to the primary domain, and, at worst, can cause the duplicate content issues to begin to spread to the primary domain and impair your rankings.
Websites running on hosts that use the Apache server software usually have it the easiest in this regard because they can control this problem on their own using the .htaccess control file. Just create a simple text file named ".htaccess" (with no filename extension), and insert the following command:
Simply replace "yourmainsite.com" in the above code with
your primary website's domain name and "duplicatesite.com" with the name
of your duplicate domain. Websites based on Microsoft's IIS Server Software
need to consult their system administrator for help. Again, be sure the server
returns the redirecting result code #301 or you're not really repairing it. A code 302
redirect will not do the job properly or reliably. You can check the result code that your server sends
using my Server Result Checker.
Another instance where a webmaster might have duplicate content issues is when they
operate separate domains for different contries. Often, there will be information that is important to
include on all such sites. For those pages where the content is identical, or nearly so, it is a good
idea to use the rel="canonical" tag on all such pages to point to a single, best quality
version to tell the search engines to only index this "canonical" version. The syntax is:
<link rel="canonical" href="http://www.example.com/canonical-page.html">
The search engines treat this tag much like a 301 redirect. It prevents duplicate
content problems while providing users with local copies of important pages. See my SEO Tips article on
the rel="canonical" tag
for more information on how this tag works and how to use it.
This page was last updated on May 26, 2015
Need More Help?
You'll find more SEO Tips on the menu on the right side of this page.
You can also contact me with your SEO questions.
If you can't fix your website search engine problems on your own,
my Search Engine Optimization Services
can give your website what it needs to get your business' fair share of search engine traffic quickly, without disturbing your website's design, and without breaking your budget.
Call Richard L. Trethewey at Rainbo Design in Minneapolis today at 612-408-4057 from 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM Central time
to get started on an affordable website design package or search engine optimization program for your small business today!
In writing these SEO tips, I'm often reminded of a pearl of wisdom that my high school computer programming teacher passed on from one of his teachers, "Computers are high-speed idiots!" Remember that, and don't let them get under your skin.